Third-Party Sick Pay: What Employers Need to Know About Payroll Requirements

Woman in bright yellow reflective vest looking at a tablet. BMA Payroll helps small businesses gain transparency and cut costs.

When an insurer pays your employee’s disability benefits, who withholds, who deposits, and who reports?

When an employee is out because of illness or injury, their pay does not always come from your payroll. Often the state disability plan or private insurer, a health and welfare fund, or another outside party makes the payments. The IRS calls this third-party sick pay, and it splits tax responsibilities between you and the payer. If the split isn’t managed, the result can be mismatched Forms 941 and W-2, IRS notices, and unhappy employees. This post explains how it works and what to do about it.

What counts as third-party sick pay?

Sick pay is any payment made to an employee under a plan because of sickness or injury while they are temporarily absent from work. It is “third-party” sick pay when someone other than the employer makes the payment, such as a short-term disability carrier or a union benefit fund. Some payments that look similar are not sick pay. State workers’ compensation payments, disability retirement payments, and reimbursements of medical expenses fall outside these rules.

How sick pay is taxed

  • Social Security and Medicare (FICA): Subject to FICA for the first six calendar months after the month the employee last worked. After that, FICA no longer applies. If the employee returns to work and later goes out again, the six-month clock restarts.
  • FUTA: Follows the same six-month window.
  • Federal income tax: Always taxable. Employees can request withholding by giving the payer Form W-4S, which sets minimum withholding amounts. A collective bargaining agreement may specify withholding instead.
  • Additional Medicare Tax: The 0.9% is withheld from the employee on wages above $200,000. There is no employer match.

Who is responsible: the employer or the payer?

The answer depends on whether the payer acts as your agent. If the third party is your agent, you are treated as the payer. You handle deposits and reporting as if you had made the payments yourself.

If the third party is not your agent, it generally owes both the employee and employer shares of FICA and FUTA. It can transfer the employer’s share to you by doing three things:

  1. Withholding the employee’s share of Social Security and Medicare from the sick pay.
  2. Depositing the withheld amounts on time.
  3. Notifying you of the sick pay paid and the taxes withheld and deposited, within the time required for the deposit.

If any step is missed, liability stays with the third party. If all three are done, liability moves to you, and you report and pay the employer share on your own Form 941 (and Form 940 for FUTA).

Form 8922: the third-party sick pay recap

When liability is transferred, the employee and employer portions end up on different returns. The payer’s Form 941 shows the employee share, and yours shows the employer share. Form 8922 reconciles the two sets of returns with the Forms W-2. It does not change anyone’s tax liability.

  • Who files: The party that did not issue the W-2. If you issue the W-2s, the insurer or agent files. If the insurer issues them, you file. Only one party files.
  • What it reports: Six annual totals: sick pay subject to income tax, income tax withheld, sick pay subject to Social Security, Social Security tax withheld, sick pay subject to Medicare, and Medicare tax withheld (including Additional Medicare Tax).
  • Where and when: It is filed with the IRS, not the Social Security Administration, by the last day of February after the year the sick pay was paid. If that date falls on a weekend or holiday, it moves to the next business day. For 2025 sick pay, the due date is March 2, 2026.
  • When it is not needed: If the third party pays all taxes and issues the W-2s under its own EIN, or acts as your agent, there is no split reporting and no recap.

Quick reference

Scenario

Who deposits and reports

Form 8922?

Third party is the employer’s agent

Employer is treated as the payer and handles deposits and W-2 reporting

No

Third party keeps all liability and issues the W-2s

Third party pays both FICA shares and reports on its own returns

No

Liability transferred; employer issues the W-2s

Employer pays the employer share on Form 941; third party reports the employee share

Yes, filed by the insurer or agent

Liability transferred; third party issues the W-2s

Employer pays the employer share on Form 941; third party reports the employee share

Yes, filed by the employer

Best practices for payroll teams

  • Know your arrangements. Identify every carrier or fund that pays sick or disability benefits and confirm whether each is your agent.
  • Get the paperwork. Ask carriers for their sick pay statements and timely notices of amounts paid and taxes withheld. Late notices are a common source of errors.
  • Assign an owner. Decide in January who files Form 8922 and who issues the W-2s, so the form is not missed by both parties.
  • Reconcile before filing. Compare carrier statements with your Forms 941 and W-2 totals before year-end filings.
  • Check state rules. Some states treat sick pay differently for unemployment insurance and may have separate reporting rules.
  • Keep records. Retain employment tax records, including your Form 8922 support, for at least four years.

Bottom line

Third-party sick pay is manageable once you know who is withholding, who is depositing, and who is reporting. Confirm the arrangement with each payer, collect the notices on time, and reconcile at year-end. If you need help sorting out your obligations, our payroll team is happy to assist.

Sources: IRS Publication 15-A and the IRS Form 8922 page. This post is general information, not tax or legal advice. Confirm current rules and deadlines with the IRS or a tax professional.